Birth-First Parent Blog

05/24/07

One Birth Mother Voice

Posted by : Jan Baker in Birth-First Parent Blog at 08:50 am , 459 words, 170 views  
Categories: Birth/First Parents


As an adoptive parent, do you want to link yourself with all adoptive parents, the good, the bad and everything in between? Do you try to speak for all adoptive parents, including the "Mommie Dearest" type adoptive parents? How about those adoptive parents in the news lately for caging their children? Can you relate to that type of adoptive parent at all?

Do you want people to think of all adoptive parents as one enormous group, all the same? I would be very surprised if any adoptive parent wants to be viewed as the voice for all adoptive parents. Birth parents usually feel that way as well.

Unless you live in a cave, however, you already know that abusive, drug-addicted birth parents exist. The news and forums are full of negative portrayals of birth parents. Even some television shows perpetuate horrible stereotypes of birth parents.


SPONSOR
Birth parents have been portrayed as cold, heartless and dysfunctional people for decades, and people need to know that not all of us are like that. There is a need to shed some light on real birth parents and that is part of what I try to do.

It would probably take spending the next fifty years writing about birth parents who do not fit the decades old stereotypes to even begin to change the public's perceptions about birth parents. The point is not to paint all birth parents as saintly beings, but as individuals. Just like adoptive parents, we are all different.

To speak up as a birth parent to the world at large takes extraordinary courage. To devote your life to reforming adoption takes unparalleled dedication. To strive to heal yourself and recover takes determination and a brave spirit. To even survive the loss of a child for any reason takes strength. The birth parents I know are doing those things, and that is why the birth parents that I know are such amazing individuals.

Adoptive parents have courageous and brave individuals among their midst as well. Many are adoption.com bloggers. They may have much in common with each other, but they want to be known not as saints, but as caring individuals. There is probably no one who wants to represent all adoptive parents.

One birth mother voice? In fact, I have zero interest in speaking for ALL birth parents. I write about my life, my experiences and those of my birth parent friends and acquaintances. There is no one voice for all birth mothers, nor should there be. I write about the other side of the coin, birth parents who are average decent human beings. Negative portrayals of birth parents have had enough press.


Further Reading:


What Does a Birthmother Look Like?

Telling the World

Photo by Jan Baker 2007

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Angela [Member] Email · http://ukraine.adoptionblogs.com/
love the post
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 09:29
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
To speak up as a birth parent to the world at large takes extraordinary courage. To devote your life to reforming adoption takes unparalleled dedication. To strive to heal yourself and recover takes determination and a brave spirit. To even survive the loss of a child for any reason takes strength.

Amen.

I thought that when you wrote about it yesterday/the other day. We don't expect that all adotpive parents are going to be silenced into not speaking just because some among them are abusive. We don't expect that all parents whose children came to them biologically are going to cease speaking about their lives just because some among them are drug-addicted. So why should we expect birth parents who lead decent, respectable lives to shut their mouths just because some among them (us) are drug addicted, abusive and/or any list of negative things.

I won't shut up just because some in society think that we SHOULD continue to be portrayed as the scum of the parenting chain. I won't shut up just because some other parents need my niche to be "less than" so they can feel validated. I won't shut up just because someone among those who share my title are not good parents. In fact, those are all reasons for me to KEEP SPEAKING. Duh. ;)
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 10:00
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
"...some other parents need my niche to be "less than" so they can feel validated"

I think this is a key point. Some parents can't handle the fact that we are their equals.
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 12:14
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
Ps - Interesting how those who are being asinine about birth mothers have avoided THIS post. Interesting indeed.
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 19:39
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Do you want people to think of all adoptive parents as one enormous group, all the same?

Unfortunatly I think a lot of us feel like we ARE all associated as one big group by some other members of the triad. This asociation is mostly negative too.
I think if adoptive parents have experienced a birthparent who is operating from a place of dysfunction they believe they have an even clearer motive for adopting the children involved, but others seem to feel it is never acceptable, or only under their defined circumstances. We have already said that every circumstance is different, so why are all infant placements defined as the same by some? Do they know the individuals and the circumstances?
I have no problem with being an equal with the birthparents of my children, but I won't be treated as less than that either.

It is hard as adoptive parents to reconcile your daily life, and have a positive impact on children who are caught in the middle, when you are seen so negatively by so many. I agree this is also true for birthparents who are struggling to be seen in a positive light.

p.s. Just curious Jenna, who do you feel is being asinine?
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 20:14
Comment from: romee_1101 [Member] Email
Good heavens. Who ever insinuated that birthparents should not speak? Nor have I ever assumed birthparents belonged in some group of dysfunctionality (like ANYONE has a corner on that market). Personally, I do not feel "more than" my son's birthmother. What an arrogant sentiment that would be and how unhelpful for him.

I don't always agree with everything I read on this blog or others, but isn't that the point? How else does anything change or how do people grow if we don't at least have a dialogue?

Romee
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 21:28
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
Great post Jan!
PermalinkPermalink 05/24/07 @ 23:10
Comment from: John [Member] Email
Hi Jan, I am sure you are right, no one wants to be the voice for all of either group. The key to avoiding that impression is disclosure.

Implying that all of either group is either all good or all bad in not realistic and definately puts the writer on the slippery slope. There are good and bad parents in each group. I would think the key to avoiding misundrstandings is clear disclosure. If the writer is speaking about their personal experiences or people they have known, that probably needs to be stated clearly.

I think the other thing that would put the writer on that same slippery slope, is lumping all of the other group into one category. If you are talking about all of the other group, then surely you are also talking about all of your group.

Speaking is always appropriate. Problems come up when it isn't clear what is being spoken about. John
PermalinkPermalink 05/25/07 @ 00:17
Comment from: Lauren [Member] Email
I'm confused as to why anyone would read a person's blog/forum post/message, etc and assume that they WERE trying to speak for everyone as a whole.
Every time I read something on ANY site (adoption related or not), I always enter with the assumption that this person is drawing on their OWN experience and what THEY know and this will shape how THEY write and feel; it doesn't have to shape ME unless I choose to let it.
Unless there was some evidence that someone has come down from on high (or up from underneath in some cases, haha) and crowned this person "Ultimate Voice For All Peoples Who Happen To Fall Into This Specific Category In Life", I have never thought that someone who was sharing PERSONAL thoughts and feelings was the ONLY voice for a position.

And how tiring it would be to have to read a paragraph of disclaimers and "self-justifications" before you could actually get to the heart of a post. That would surely turn me off to reading and educating myself.

Anyway, maybe we should all just remember that MOST (READ: NOT ALL- for those who need that much clarification) of these adoption forums and blogs are for HEALING and EDUCATION and REFORM. The easiest place to start all 3 of those processes are close to home, ie drawing from personal experience. We don't all have to agree, but we have NO right to make one person's pain less than our own.
PermalinkPermalink 05/25/07 @ 08:10
Comment from: Nicole [Member] Email · http://paragraphein.wordpress.com
John: seriously.

What do you want Jan to do? Post a disclaimer on the top of every post that says, "I know not all birth parents are good people. This post is for/about the ones who are."?

She DOES acknowledge that some bio parents actually need to relinquish.

What else do you want from her?

PermalinkPermalink 05/25/07 @ 13:42
Comment from: John [Member] Email
Nicole, you are right. A disclaimer would be kind of impractial on every post. 'My experience with other birth mothers...', says it all, there is no doubt that this is not about all of the group. The opposite is 'Birthmothers feel ...', which seems to talk about the entire group. I would think it is much like any type of communication, choose your words carefully. John
PermalinkPermalink 05/27/07 @ 16:01
Comment from: aimeew [Member] Email
I became a birthmother almost 20 years ago and things were not as progressive in some ways as they are now. I mean when Cheryl Crow is on the cover of a magazine with her newly adopted son, the topic of adoption is "out there".

The thing is, even as popular as the topic is becoming with the media (good and bad), we have an opportunity to have our voice heard...to have our experiences known.

To be realistic, I do not think that people think of all adoptive parents are of the same caliber. Nor do believe that all birthparents are viewed in the same manner, either. There may be a lot of misunderstanding and a load of education needed, but I would hope that we would not be lumped in the same category. We have some things in common, but that does not mean we are cut from the same cloth.

"The point is not to paint all birth parents as saintly beings, but as individuals. Just like adoptive parents, we are all different."

We cannot forget that in our similarity, we can find strength. In our differences, we can actually learn more about ourselves.

PermalinkPermalink 05/29/07 @ 20:33
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Related Discussions

    http://www.omnitrace.com

    Misc

    Subscribe to Birth-First Parent Blog

     Enter your email address:
     

     

    Who's Online?

    • Guest Users: 132