Birth-First Parent Blog

06/20/07

Lost Children

Posted by : Jan Baker in Birth-First Parent Blog at 08:03 am , 336 words, 84 views  
Categories: Things to Think About



Some people take offense when a birth parent refers to having "lost a child to adoption." However, I do not quite comprehend that rationale. When a child is placed in a closed adoption, its first parents lose their normal parental rights to have any contact with that child, know their identity or how they are doing.

When placing a child in a closed adoption, that child is in essence lost forever in the eyes of their birth parents. There is no certainty that you will ever know who or where your child is living, how they are faring or even if they are still alive.

In my view that IS losing a child. You may or may not lose the chance to ever see your child or know their fate. A reunion is in a sense as if a lost child comes back from the dead. For birth parents who have tried to sever the bond in their minds, it may feel as though your child is resurrecting themselves.

SPONSOR

I mean no disrespect to anyone who has lost a child to death, as I know that is final and different. All I am saying is that may be how it feels to a birth parent. Some birth parents deal with the loss of their child by banishing thoughts of that child as a survival technique.

As terrible as it sounds, a birth parent might try to pretend that their child never existed. In a sense, dealing with the loss might be easier that way. It can be a tremendous shock when a child suddenly reappears when you never expect that they will.

Most birth parents are unable to banish thoughts of their children from their minds. However, they still lost the right to parent, to watch their children grow and all the rest that being a parent entails. "Lost" does not always mean that something is hidden and cannot be found.

Further Reading:

Are Adoptees Lost?

Core Issues in Adoption - Loss


Photo by Jan Baker 2007

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: erin_d_a [Member] Email
I don't understand why people get their panties in a bunch either when moms refer to their placed children as lost to adoption. I lost a child to miscarriage. I am not able to parent my child(ren) because I miscarried them, that is what they were lost to. So you lost them to adoption. The problem is so many people in adoption land, especially aparents, want it to be sunshine and lollipops, so they see the word "lost" as a big negative, of which they refuse acknowledge exists in adoption.

Sorry for the novel, but I've been feisty lately.
PermalinkPermalink 06/20/07 @ 13:07
Comment from: franklymydear [Member] Email
It's offensive not because of any disrespect to those who have had children die or due to any naive misunderstanding about "lost" being taken literally as "unable to find".
It is offensive because the phrase "lost a child to X" traditionally carries connotations of X being intrinsically a source of nothing but badness/evil/darkness. People lose children to smallpox. They lose children to drugs. They lose children to schizophrenia. You would never, for example, hear someone say of their teen prodigy "I lost my child to the piano" except jokingly.
This connotation intrinsic in the phrase means that referring to children as "lost" to adoption is tantamount to calling adoptive parents evil.

Now to be clear: To the birthparent it is unquestionably a loss and no one is denying that. I'm simply pointing out why the use of the specific phrase "lost to adoption" is offensive.
PermalinkPermalink 06/20/07 @ 13:40
Comment from: John [Member] Email
Interesting post Jan. Franklymydear, you are right. It is offensive, and it does imply something very negative about adoption and adoptive parents.

Let me suggest a more correct way to say the bit about lost child. 'The birth mother, after consdering the advice of others (which may not have been correct) chose to lose her child to adoption.' This puts the action together with the only person who could take that action. Said that way, is it still the way a birthmother would talk about her child, or should the word lost get lost.

My dictionary only talks about something hidden or that can't be found as lost. There must be a bigger dictionary that has other definitions.

'Lost to adoption' is still light years less offensive than just 'lost', as some bloggers insist. Thanks for being more accurate Jan.

A child placed in closed adoption must be a terrible loss for the birth parent. Not using the word lost does not mean that there is no loss. John
PermalinkPermalink 06/20/07 @ 15:54
Comment from: Sunbonnet Sue [Member] Email
As an adoptive parent, it does not offend me one little bit to hear a first parent refer to their child as "lost," or "lost to adoption." The feelings and intent seem clear, and completely unrelated to me or my life. It's not like they're saying I stole their child, only that they no longer have access or information. This seems perfectly understandable, if one of my children was unavailable to me for any reason, it would certainly feel as if they were "lost." It makes sense for parents, adoptive or placing, to use the word that best describes their situation and experience.
PermalinkPermalink 06/21/07 @ 08:22
Comment from: jpdakota43 [Member] Email
I never quite understood the "lost to adoption" phrase myself. I guess it would apply in cases where a child is permanently removed without the birth parents' awareness of it or intent of it. Having said that, I don't know a better term, I guess. I think Frankly has a good point, though. That is the connotation of lost.
Truth is, the birth parents can call it whatever makes sense to them. But as an adoptee I get to decide, too, and I was most definitely not lost.
PermalinkPermalink 06/21/07 @ 21:56
Comment from: soblessed [Member] Email
I can understand "lost to adoption" in cases where coercion or baby swiping was involved.

I guess I would be a little less understanding in a situation where a child was removed from the home for their own safety or when a mother voluntarily relinquishes without coercion.
PermalinkPermalink 06/28/07 @ 16:20
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

http://www.omnitrace.com

Misc

Subscribe to Birth-First Parent Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • grendlina
  • Guest Users: 141