http://www.omnitrace.com/birth-family.html
Birth-First Parent Blog

02/02/07

Fresh Outlook Friday: When Thoughts Change

Posted by : Jenna Hatfield in Birth-First Parent Blog at 12:45 pm , 938 words, 148 views  
Categories: Noteworthy Websites/Blogs, On Motherhood
Separate?This week, as the snow piles on us again, I feel a little heavier. It's not just because I've been eating Polish pastries (Paczki days are here!). It's not to be blamed on the snow because, trust me, I love snow. As much as I love winter, I start struggling with emotional things round about now. This year is harder for reasons I don't feel like talking about today. And so, today's "fresh outlook" is a deeper, harder look at some adoption issues. Controversial? A bit. Worth a ponder before you start your weekend? Probably. New and different? Definitely.

Boomerific posted a thoughtful, heart-felt, deep and heavy post yesterday regarding birthing a child, separation, birth parents, adoption, relinquishment and revocation. I had to read it in small bits and pieces because, in my struggles this month, too much adoption emotion (or emotion in general) can send me over the edge. I kept coming back to it throughout the day (and night and again today) before I realized that it fit perfectly into the Fresh Outlook Friday series.

It fits here not just because some of the questions being posed, which we will get to shortly, are new and different (they are) but because Boomerific herself is experiencing a new and fresh outlook, different from some of the things she has felt and believed in the past, and she admits it in this post. Sometimes it's hard to admit when our own thoughts and beliefs change, especially if we have been so adamant about them in the past. I think that deserves a pat on the back. Now, onto the post.

First and foremost, I think the world needs to read this and tattoo it on their hearts:

Long before I ever intended to became a mother through childbirth I held to one very crucial principle: you can’t (or shouldn’t) adopt until you can acknowlege that such circumstances could arise that would compel you to give up your own children. People who say, “I could never do that!” should not adopt. Women who relinquish are ordinary women of all ages, races, and social classes who face difficult cirumstances. To assume that you yourself could never find yourself in similar cirumstances is the height of arrogance and naivitee. And this goes for domestic and international adoption.

It wasn’t until I knew love for this separate person, my son, at six weeks, that I knew in my heart I could give him up if I needed to. The issue is complicated of course, and who knows where I would draw the line. Having known the love of an expectant adoptive parent I knew it was possible–gut-wrenching, horrific, but possible–to trust someone else to raise my child. But I needed to love him first.

SPONSOR
http://omnitrace.com/


Immediately after reading these two paragraphs, I got up and left my computer. As tears fell down my cheeks, I sat on my bed, clutching the Munchkin's blankie, and thought about those words. I, myself, have said before that I am just like every other woman on the planet: just one who faced a difficult decision and did the best that she thought she could with what she was offered. However, it doesn't seem to make a difference with a birth mother claims that she's just like Jane, Sally and Mary. Jane, Sally and Mary don't feel that way. So, when Jane's sister nudges Jane and says, "No, really, she IS just like you," it touches me.

Furthermore, I've never honestly heard an adoptive mother (or a mother by birth, such as this example) ever say, "I could do this if I absolutely had to do so." I don't think I've read it on a blog. (If you know of someone who has written about it, please link me. I'd also like to thank them.) I know I haven't heard it in discussion with other moms. So, again, I was brought to tears by the fact that someone understood on that strange level that many mothers refuse to visit.

From there, things tend to get a little controversial and, even for me, "different." Boomerific provides her personal feelings on the topic of relinquishment, if it was her, stating that she would have needed to parent for six weeks in order to make the right decision. I encourage you to visit her blog and read the rest of it and get involved in a respectful conversation. Boomerific asks questions at the end of her post that I think you should answer over there. Over here, I simply encourage my readers to think about some of these things. If you've never thought about having no other decision but to let someone else parent your child, think about it. Just for a moment. If you feel uncomfortable with the other things suggested, just simply let yourself feel that specific part of the post.

On top of that, I encourage all members of the triad to think about how your own outlook has changed over the years. Know that it will continue to change and morph as your experiences mould your thoughts, emotions and being. Our lives and hearts change shape. You may start out as a square but turn into a circle. Admitting that you have changed isn't always easy. But when we stop trying to push ourselves in a square-shaped-hole, we fit much better into our new circular lives. And so my questions are:

How have your thoughts changed over the years? Does it feel weird to admit it? Why? How do you explain to others how and why your feelings and beliefs have changed?

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: mommamarci [Member] Email
Jenna,
Right after Hurricane Katrina hit I was at a friend's house. They were showing coverage of parents putting their very sick children on helicopters and trusting the doctors and nurses to get them to safety, not knowing if they (the parents) would make it to safety and see their children again. A friend (who had a child) said she could never do that. I (who did not yet have a child) immediately responded, "If I was given a choice of getting my child to safety and possibly never seeing him again, or keeping my child and the child possibly not making it, I would not even have to think about that one. I would beg them to take care of my baby and kiss him good-bye."

I had forgotten that. This story reminded me of that. I could never pretend to understand what first mothers are going through / have gone through, but we (mothers) are all alike. Fortunately, I have not encountered the situations they did. But our roles could have very easily been reversed. Giving Cameron up would be the hardest choice I would ever make, but I love him enough that I (think) I could make that choice if it was in his best interest.

One of my biggest pet peeves is when people assume Cameron's first mom did not love him. She did. Her love for him was so strong she made a huge sacrifice because she thought it was better for him. Some days I think I will never be able to live up to that love. I hope Cameron (and my future children) can understand this and realize how blessed they are to have 2 moms.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 12:57
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
One of my biggest pet peeves is when people assume Cameron's first mom did not love him. She did.

Marci, it's one of my biggest pet peeves as well. I spend so much time and energy trying to convince people that I love the Munchkin... it's frustrating!

That was a good comparison, Marci. Thank you for sharing that with me/us. Something else for us all to consider.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 13:00
Comment from: Holly [Member] Email · http://africa-adoption.adoptionblogs.com
No arguments from me. One important step that some birthparents seem to skip is "claiming" that child. How can you say goodbye to someone that was part of you and your life, when you never really said hello, or "I love you"? It has always bothered me when I hear young women who are planning on placing their babies for adoption talk about how the baby is not really theirs, but the Brown's (or whatever). THey don't name them, they don't talk to them and they don't "claim" them. I would venture to say that "claiming" is a critical component of "letting go". (And would I choose my child/children over me? You bet.)
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 13:31
Comment from: JudyK [Member] Email · http://justenjoyhim.wordpress.com/
Oh my. My thoughts and feelings have changed a great deal over the years. In fact, they've changed a lot just over the past year. Is it weird to admit it? -- yes, in a way. Weird or maybe just difficult to articulate. In fact, I've had a post percolating in my head about this very topic, for a few weeks anyways.

It's all complicated, and that's why I think it's difficult to put into words. Quite honestly, Jenna, a lot of the changes have taken place by reading blogs of members in different parts of the triad -- people like you.

I also hate the "I could never do that" phrase, because I think that none of us ever knows what we could or would do given a certain set of circumstances. It smacks of arrogance to say that. I hope that there are circumstances where I would do exactly that things, give my child to someone else, if it meant his safety over mine. It would break my heart, but if it would save his life, you bet I would do it, in a heartbeat.

People never know what they would do until faced with the exact same circumstances that someone else is put into. They just don't know.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 13:35
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
Saying that you could "never do that," implies that birth mothers are "different" and do not love their children. I hear you Jenna - I too spend a great deal of time trying to convince others I love my relinquished son.

My feelings about adoption changed dramatically the instant I heard the words, "your son is searching for you." They have evolved more as I have met others in so much pain. Certain opinions will change; some will not.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 14:15
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Jenna, Great post!
Yes I have thought about this same issue for personal reasons but also other things push it up to the surface now and again.
Back in 2004 do you remember the Russian school where children and parents were held hostage for days?

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/01/20/48hours/main668127.shtml

During that time I recall the news showing footage of the mothers with young babies as they were being released. One mother being released quickly passed her infant to a startled woman who was helping the released hostage exit and she ran back into the school to stay with her older child.
I just remember reacting so emotionally to her brave decision. I mean here were other mothers being released with their infants, each with older children inside, yet they left with the babies. This mother was pushed to make a choice, weighed her options and she had but a second to do so. This mom decided to hand her child to a stranger because she KNEW the baby would be taken out to safety. She chose to go back and stay with her older child,not knowing if they would ever make it out alive (many did not).
My recant may not capture the emotion I felt seeing that footage, but it was intense for me.
This mother was forced to make a choice no parent ever thinks they will have to make, yet there she was. She decided in a split second to do what she thought would best keep both her children safe.
None of us think we will ever be faced with such a choice, it seems to awful to consider, yet none of us can say "Not ME", because we just do not know.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 14:25
Comment from: Galaxykitten [Member] Email
I wanted to comment on the not me pet peev My thoughts on this have changed in the last month about this .But let me tell you alittle background and why Ive changed.
It took me 3 yrs to concieve due to infertility problems and about 3 months before we got pregnant with my 1st duaghter we looked into adoption but I know know I wasn't ready for that I had the notion how could these parents give up such a great gift I need to save some of these babies yes I was in the baby only mind set too!But looking though these profiles and after haveing two children that are boilogical yes I still want to adopt but I'm thinking up to a 5 yr old and I'm thinking not saveing but providing and recieving such a great gift.I look at these comments and it dawned on me ofcourse if there was a split second chance to save my girls while I might perish I would do it in a heart beat.
So what makes me so different I believe any mother that has chosen adoption for her baby has done it as a neccisity and out of love I can't think of anyone that would say well im too rich or too bored to have a kid around .There is som much troubles broken families unplaned pregnances unable to support a child drugs ect ect ect .I want to give my love to those mothers that give up there child for them to live.I'm sorry that there are so many that don't understand you have to understand we arent trying to be mean or unthoughtful I believe most people say I would never out of fear.I thank you for helping me grow and alter my personal view piont on this subject. :)
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 16:05
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Oh, Jenna, it seems that my thoughts change on a daily/weekly/monthly basis about adoption. I used to think if you were of a certain age you would make that great of a mom but growing up and watching a newphew and his girlfriend parents have prooved to me that young teens can make good parents when they want to... I'm getting off topic but my point is my thoughts and feelings are everchanging and I think that's just part of growing older!

Good post!!

Is that you in the picture?
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 16:49
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
Coley,

I guess that I have never doubted that young moms can be good parents as I was one myself. When my daughter was born, I was not quite 17 years old.

Wanting to parent and believing that you can is a great deal of what makes it possible for teen parents - not everything - but a lot.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 17:32
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Wanting to parent and believing that you can is a great deal of what makes it possible for teen parents - not everything - but a lot.

I get that now, but if you had asked me that at 15 I would not have gotten that. I don't think I would have made a good parent at 15, but then again I wasn't presented the option. I thought the world was black and white and I think part of growing up is learning that it is not.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 20:32
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
It seems to me that anyone who insists they couldn't hand a child into the permanent care of others has a very limited imagination. Either that, or they have no children and little understanding of the enormity of love that comes with being a mother.
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 22:22
Comment from: ginny [Member] Email
It wasn't until I became a mother that I realized I COULD give up my child if it was in their best interest. Before that, I, too, thought, "I could never do that."
PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 22:55
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
"I thought the world was black and white and I think part of growing up is learning that it is not."

I think that is very true Coley. One of the problems in adoption is that people try to make it too simple (black and white). But, it just isn't.

PermalinkPermalink 02/02/07 @ 23:59
Comment from: Veronika [Member] Email
I've always been one of the "I'll never do that" tribe. This past year has changed our lives so much and given new perspective on so many things. We always thought that no matter what happened, we'd be ok. Within two weeks we had to sell our house, the home we built for our children and thought we'd live in forever, to keep from loosing everything. Within six weeks we were living with my parents because we simply didn't have the money to pay for a roof over our heads. Never say never. I've come to realize that you sometimes have to make decisions that you never thought you'd have to.
PermalinkPermalink 02/03/07 @ 03:33
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
I think that is very true Coley. One of the problems in adoption is that people try to make it too simple (black and white). But, it just isn't.Amen to that one Jan!!
PermalinkPermalink 02/03/07 @ 07:27
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

   

Misc

Subscribe to Birth-First Parent Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 124